Anandabazar Patrika

Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial

5 YAv 1413 cyS} 22 PM9G} 2006

DStc {HMw...

}SAWc {~M ySgSA~ P~SwSm

P{H PfSM} Xyr YMye _c (Y yS w 15 Xe 2006) AvyM} wA}M<AMr _Z w YA v2H} mAc ZAS wAAv, rS} Av|SmJc \wSwvS} jv uvySt AyMr, jSAr}SW yvS{ zrS} &5 AvM Y}a _cyS} Y{SMt} ezH} zSMy zSAyr c}S} jv

47 wyyrH zS}Mr} ZArS, zS}rH zrS} ZArS, zS}rH }SW-_} v rr Atv XyAu PcSva }SAWc uS}qS Y{SMt} aw} PhMw yMAv cOvS c}Mr ZM , PtzSe vS M~ Yj }SWzSS (vS Ac }SjzSS!) cH r AA2zSH Y} wSSwSA wSNS PtaS \tzSH cS} zSSMc <SuSv PtaS r? AyS~ dc yzSH} tSAyMcZ yS cH zSMy PtdS r?

47-_} Pt zSe v, yS~S zSeZ MrS ySgSA~} XyHSyH Ayw|M} hvS ASMy ZArSM P~dS sScMy R yiM}} ySgSA~ Ar Yj A&dAr XuS zS}r }SMW} }SAWc Ar} YSMv Ayw7, |At yS Ay~<S vSa ; ySAc XMuc }SWH wMwScrS {Ser Z~SA{c}Mq Y{, XsNvArc KtMv XAycAr P|-Atv AycAr My, rSMc Ac Y} P-Atv ySgSA~} Ar y~S |SMy? MrS |SMy P-Atv a wSM}} PhSMd PmSZ My <cr ySgSA~ Ar, Y} _-wSM}}mS ZASv Ar Xv AtMc, _-wSM}} PhSMd a-wSM}}mS My Z~SA{c Ar, Y} _-wSM}}mS cH jSAv, MrS eMyqSSMw

dAr tZ yH Ar w}} PsMc { tM} M} P|Mr sScMy Pc\Z Y} AvMjMc yAr} Ssc \}A} PzMy Y5SfS PySu c}S} jSeS sScMy vS {M} PRSMr }SMW} cSMi, }SAWc {~-_} cSMi AyAcM |SaSZ Ac ySgSA~} zAyry? ySgSA~}? ySgSA~ Ar}? ySgSA~ jSrHrSySMt}?
}SjHy h2 {Svw}, ySM~, deA~

PycS} ZAbAvS} Av{Sq

PtyHtS YhSM|} {Sv AMc, rSA~cS} r~SAv PsMca iS zAr (30/8) _McySM} |sSs YM~ShvS _ yS} P|-Atv <s{ cS\MA~ MAi~ P-Atv ShM PtMd Ar zS~ P~MeAi~ AyS}, kSd, \}<Mt PsMc _c kS>c ASsH  XAzzSyMc} < csSySrS }SjySH AMMy XAzzr MAi~S{ |Ata jSAv XMvc \SAz~SH <s{ wi2 AMMy ySSM~SM} hM~ PeMi, ry wDZ{y }cSM}} PymS} P~m tSv PvzS} <S A}zS PvM!v PnAcMMi XMvcmSZ Pv-P!va!

_} w} PdMw PdMw P| zSMy 69000 XyAu oScS ~, rSMr zS~ ~SeS \My PeMi Y} y~S |SMy vS jM* _+S w}HS wS cM} rMyZ ZAbAvSA} wS} M|Se PwMMi ({Sv AMc, rSA~cS} r~SAv PsMc iS zAr Y yS w 30-8) {SM~Shc y~Mr wSM}v, eqrSAc }SMW AS} M|Se y c}S |SAv, |SMy vS Ac yMc Sr AtM y~S |S Ac P|, oSSA}-ZAbAvSA}M} {MrS \AS SuS}q {SMv} \wM|SeH c}Mr My? <s{ PsMc A&rH yiM} P| !w-Y\m cT My rS cH cM} S{~SMy }Sj }cS}?

<ArMytMv y~S MMi, Yv dSA~ sScS} csS AtMv} YM~S} {MrS r, M}} ySZM} _ y cM~Mj AMc}S Av a }AyyS} S cM}v XsS Pr{v SH xScSB PvZ PdSt YZYZCm d`w} zeMi _} w} wA}cSnSM{S a P=M{* ry YS ySMi, cS}q YeS{H Xr t yiM} ZvxM{v PmcMvS~AjMr _r hScA}} XycS KrA} My _ }SMj P| y cM~j PjSeSv AtMr wS}My vS rSZ Py}cSA} ZAbAvSA} AS AvM |S>}S yyS c}Mr hSZMiv, r>SMt} PwSSySM}S

Ac XMvc YS AvM |S>}S eM <S Arv PsMc hS} ~ mScS pS~Myv, rS>Mt} Ssz M~ P| Kv}Sj Px} KrA} My, rS} tS Pc PvMy? _cZ M ySMi n~S |{ Av{SvyArrS} XzSy y A{A~M Ay{ x~ ySM~ ~SMz} ` PZ EwwMZ PdM PvMy

\AS} PM `qer {Sv yjS }SdMrZ My <ArMytv Xv|SH PdS~S {Mv YM~ShvS a wvAyMyhvS} csS h~Mi eM hS} ~ mScS Py}cSA} AyAvMSecS}H} SMr rM~ PycS} ZAbAvS} Av{Sq cr t} x~< \AS txr} _y AyajMv}S XyZ AyMyhvS c}Myv
cCScc{S} }S xmcMeSS, h2vve}

AjvhM zeySv

[}AySM} wM SSjSeSMvS yZ t ~SMSMj Xy eo yZCm} \wjHy XyZ [}AyS, Y} rS} P~dc dSAr{Sv AyaSvH, A\{Sv AjMvS{ P<SMjMf} XAucrS, >SA cA~v jHyjeMr AyyrMv} {sc M~a A|Av [}AySH wAsc ` AjvhM zeySv (Y yS w 26-8) }hvS _Z <M [}AyS GM eSA~A~a, Av\mv, oS}\Zv a YZvSZMv} {MrS Ayer AyaSvHMt} \A \MNd cM}Miv Hyr YZvSZMv} AhS [} AiM~v _c XMa XM~RAcc A} <r AvS Ayh}ShM} <Sq-X<Sq cM~} cSMi A|Av S<cS YA{ PZ [}Mc jSAv YA{ AyS cA}, <cAr cdva jS PdM~ vS YA{ Py Xvzy c}Mr wSA} Ay-]SM} C} {M~ YMi XMa XM~RAcc a Ah}zSS} _c AyTc} <ArzS} <r Avq YZvSZMv} _Z \ACma <AquSvM|Se
XMSc t Prjw}, X{

Aci yAer sScMy vS?

_r AtMv} _cmS PdS>hS {S}S M} XySv ~ ({r} {M oSSvS ezyrH AiM~v vS Y yS w 20.08.06) oSSvS >SA PS} (j8 1961)-_} {r  1997-_} 31 Xe PzS} hS}Mm, wSA}M} }SjwMs P{Sm} tfmvS eSAMr AiM~v A{M}} PcSCmwAr, iAy-<M|Sjc PoSAo Y~ xSMt rS>}a jHyvSySv 

_dSMv y~S \Ahr P| ySt{Su{ yd Xur yS Xr fmvSMc }h A{AM Ar} {MrS cM} wA}MyAr c}Mr wSM} cu v, rS cM}a sSMc SuS}q {Sv, SuS}q wSnc, SuS}q PSrS-tc, P My} Y~ ArmS XMvc {Z rdv jSvMr wSM}v vS _y Ar-A{Ms PySkS}-AyM5Mq} tCzA, rSAet PcSvaCmZ rSMt} SuS}qr sSMc vS

<r Yj {Mv wMr wSM}, cr vHhrS} M yStS rsS ySt{Su{`A~ oSSvSMc P { \wSwv c}r, rSMt} hmJ~ PvS}S yySH {MvSzSyMc Xs \wSjMv} \MM cSMj ~SeSMvS} jv! <Mrc {SvM} _cmS yAer jHyv YMi, |S <hS} c}S} PcSva <4Z aMn vS, |S <hS} c}S Av2vH v cu, Xw}Su{~c _y eAr cSja yMm SSsyS _Z jeMr} {Sv _{Av _{Av cS\Mc zS~ySM vS, _{Av cS}a} jv PhSMd} j~ PxM~ vS PhSMd j~ YM vS oSSvS XMvc zS~ `Mq} XAucS}H AiM~v oSSvS} Aci cCma MrS Ai~ tCzA} AvA}Md <Mrc {SvM} PtScCmMc \wSwv c}S |S oSSvS }SjwA}yS} PsMc |sSM|Se ISv vSAyhS} wSvAv, oSSvSMc |y}Sj hS~ \MwS cM}AiM~v oSSvS Md} v, SA} SMv jHyMv} XMvcmS { XArySAr cM}AiM~v

oSSvSMc P| PtSM PtSSM}SMw} csS aMn, PZ _cZ cSMj, _cZ AyM |y}Sj hS~a jAr Ac P AvM Pr{v zSMy PcSva csS  vS, P y AyM Pr{v zSMy PcSva <hS} Av YjMc} AtMv P|dSMv vS}H-wTM} {SvSAucS} ZrSAt} csS y~S  PtSM-`Mq {Sv oSSvS cu w}{ _y h}{ 2}HZ v, ArAv _cjv AytH {A~S AiM~v ArAv t`Mq}, PyS{Mv} XAucSA}qHa rSZ {r} {M oSSvS ezyrH AiM~v vS _Z ySMt |Ms zS~ ~Se~
<yH} PfS yA}Sm, \} 24 w}evS

cdva PzMy PtMdMiv,
Py>Mh sScSmSa _cmS XM~RAcc fmvS

<y$ ySehH} P~dS _dSMva ~Sc c{M}o}S Av-{~yS} Av}SA{ (Y yS w 8-9) <M AyaSv{vrS, eMqM} tu dSaSMvS, SeM}} A{C j~ ZrSAt XM~RAcc cSM}} csS yM~Miv Ac aZ Ay`A~Mc <SuSv vS AtMZ y~Ai, XM|RAc zSMy yS Dq AvjS aSMv} H{Sy$rS} |A AtM u{, [}, tv yS _Z {SAyTM} jeMr Y{S} XMySu Aci fmM~Z, AyaSv{vrS} XjSMr rSMc \AM PtyS} <MhSa Ac AyaSMv} cS} Y} SM tZ Atv Pcv, SM <ArAtv Av}SA{ dSaSZ Ac YuAvc AyaSMv} w}S{ v?

<crwM AyaSv a u{ \zM}Z \M rMc d>Mj Py} c}S, YZvSZMv} {MrS AyaSvH yM~v Science is Lame without religion and religion is blind without Science. AyaSv{vrS} vSM{ {SsS uM}Mi yM~ {SsS $ PcMm Px~S} {MrS PvAryShc Y{Mq PcSva AtvZ cS} t} c}S |S vS, \w} <cr AyaSv PhrvS a u{ PhrvS P| _c PmSZ PySkS t}cS} cS} rSSMr M~ |S>}S rSSMyv, rS>Mt} YMe AyaSv{v Mr My u{, [}, wjS XvSv AyS vS c}M~Z P AyaSv{v; YMe rSSMr My aSMv} _Z H{Sy$rS Xvzy c}Mr My Py>Mh sScSmSa _cCm XM~RAcc fmvS Y} There are many things in Heaven and Earth than that philosphy dreams off

rSZ yM~ eMqMc tu dSaSy vS yS Y}y SeM}} jM~a c}y vS X{Mr} Sv
zS {j{tS} c~cSrS-61

\S~w~ hSZ

S>r}SeSAi P}~ Pv PsMc PMv cM} SaS |SrSSr c}Mr  PMv} \} AtMc XyAr PcSvS P}SMo} |SvySv yyS} c}Mr M~ Pt AcM~SA{mS} XwA}} }SUS wtMj XAr{ c}Mr , vryS Arvr~S {Sv \>h P}~Mr wS} M PcSvS P}SMo P|Mr  P}~ crw a wDZ{y }cS} |At S>r}SeSAi PMv} tAq Atc PsMc _cCm \S~w~ Av{Sq cM} PcSvS P}SMo} M M|Se c}S} yyS cM}v, rS M~ {S} {SuSv 
Ayr zShS| yScSS, SaS-711110

AyTr Z~S PfS

Yv2ySjS} wAcS {S~S \w~M} XvSMv} _cCm iAy Ptd~S{ _Z <M yA~, H{rH Z~S PfS y<s{ _Z <zSrH XvSMv ySj~ PrS{S} YM~S} Pyq eSZMrv; rdv } _cmJ Xv }c{ Ai~ H{rH PfSM} oSS} iAyMr YA{ yv y~y~ eSA eSv a P Atv cuSM~S ySqH jvA< MAi~ rS>} Xv AwMn v}jSSv v}jSSv _c {M P}AoMSMr PSvS P|r
rS {MdSwSuS c~cSrS-20

v au

au _~ v ~, |qS {}Miv cSvS} P}SeH (Y yS w 30-8) <ArAS jSvSMvS} PcSva zSS d>Mj wSD vS _a Ac Hy? cM~Z tSA _AM |SMv Ah}bv cSvS} SwSrS~ crw y~Miv, |>SMt} au AvM |SyS} csS r>S}S vSAc SS PtvAv Ac Ah}bv SwSrS~ crwM} zSMe P|mJc au <Sw Ai~, rS Ac {}qSw7 cSvS} P}SeHMt} zSMe jMmAi~? ySZ |At tSA _AM |S tSAmS Pc PvMy?
PS{vSs wS~ }yH4 }Aq, yS>cS

{A~S} x<SA

v Ac dAv tZ PySMv} xS>A} YMt (Y yS w 1-9) Hc ySMt \MNd c}S MMi, SSuHv zS}Mr Yj w| PcSva {A~S} xS>A vS aS Mxa... {Mv  _Z rsCm Cnc v }rvyS[ Kjv vS{c jNvc z({A~SMc }SjuSvH AtANMr xS>A PtaS MAi~ XuSwc Y} Au~v _y {{rS Ye}aS~-_} Probable Essays (1994) vS{c yZCmMr should Death Penalty be Abolished vS{c <yCm jSvSM: After India got her independence from the British Yoke Ratan Bai Jain was the first woman to be hanged in Indias Capital.(p-296).
rTq SAr \~MyAS, SaS