Anandabazar Patrika

AvySM}} Avy

18 YS 1417 AvyS} 3 j~SZ 2010

f*S X~ Zj aMZ~

}SM|S} Ay2S Aja x{~S dy jvA<Z MZMi Ac1 rSAvS-XvzyMt} <ArM|SAerSZ PvM{ {Mv M AvZ{ P{Mv
AvMjMc <ArS c}SZ Y~ X~ Zj aMZ~mS AvicZ xSv A~dMiv PtyeAr }SZMhRu}H a PtySbvS zShS|

ZZSAc M?

<tH PeSSS{H 29 wSm aZSMv ySc Y} wYSMSvS cM}vAv
MzMyAi~S{ _cmS Aci Anc MZ |SMy yZ c{ Ai~ } e}{ Ai~ {S-ySyS} csS cSMv AtZAv yyS c}y uHTzSZ XGSAv MZ PtAdMZ Pty u Ac ~ vS

Mcv? ~ vS Pcv? PhS cM}vAv AvZZZ zS~ cM}? wSv ySwS}mS P }c{ Ai~ vS {Mv M!
sS{v PrS! a y cMZc PcSAmMr _cmS Z Y} aZ A ZAoZm {ScS csS cvM~ eS sS~S cM} cu wSMv S} hM~ vS PwMm |dv mSv wYMy, yZ PyMY |SMy Y} PcSva cSj wSMyv vS rdv ykMyv cr uSMv cr hS~! eSAY hS~SMvS AdAi |At <SZMzm eSAY-mSAY hS~SMvS} cSj wSZ PmSa PrS AdMr M, y~v? _dv dSA~ {Mv Z wYSMSvSmS AncnSc c}M~ Xr hScA}} w}HS`M~SZ yMr wS}rS{ jHyvmS AvMj} SMrZ v c}~S{ PySuZ, rSZ vS?

M~ PrS zS~Z r, Ac1...

XAzvy y AxAjMi} iS Ay_A-} w} _dv cSvw} YZYZAm
M~ eSMv} tSTq PvS Ai~ S}S Atv cSMv PoMxSv ~SAeMZ eSv cvrS{ _{vcH ySsTM{a! ySyS-{S yS}q cM}vAv PcSva Atv Ac1 _mSa yM~Miv, wYSMSvSmS c} _cmS P~Mz~ XyAu PmS} t}cS} YMi

rS M~ eSv?
cSvwM} Y{S} _cmS cSDS yS YMi AyAz7 PxM eSv eSZMr |SZ cH My jSAv vS, Ac1 ZS YMi _mS AvMZ Aci c}S} A{\Ajc PcSDSAv`M~SMc XSM<Sh c}S

Y} YZYZAm-} wYSMSvS...?
amS PrS jHyMv} Xr jTA} _cmS X

Pcv?
eSMv} w}HSZ Px~ c}M~a |SMr hScA}} ySjS}mS PdS~S sSMc, kckMc SAMr y~M~v XAzvy

cu eSv AvMZ sScS} S PvZ y~Miv?
PvZ A ZAoZm ySvSMvS j Ac1 jHyvmS cAnv Y} Y{S} ySyS-{ S  }cSA} hScM} YA{M}} {MrS PcSAmwAr vZ Y{}S AoA vS PwM~ SM}} S~ u}y cH cM}? eSv PeMZ SfSArc Aci cM} Px~M~ xSmSxSAm Ac1 vS M~?

<tH, XAzvyMt} <4`M~S cAnv, Y} \}mS....

\} 1: <ArM|SAerS PcSsSZ PvZ?

~-cM~j UM} vS Z w}HS Y} <ArM|SAerS rM~ AtM~v, Ac1 jHyMv} Xv yY UM} PcSsSZ <ArM|SAerS PvZ y~v PrS? Y} rSM} jA{v w}-_ YA{} dSv Ac1 [SvMc jHyMv} {~ PRSMr AxA}MZ _MvAiM~v _cmS Y<cS} <ArM|SAerSZ AjArMZZ A ZAoZm-_ }SM|S w}HS {SMv vS w}HS vZ, PRx aSvSjMv AySH _c |yc P tSTq ySwS} Ac1 P XvSZSM SM xS Z _rmSZ P{uSyH ySZ Ac rS Z? xcc aZSo YyS} AyAydSr _c AyaSvH PZ AyMjSYS dSAr Ac _{Av _{Av _MMi? PcSva c, PcSva AvS iSYSZ? jHyv PsMc <ArM|SAerS ySwS}mS _McySM} PkMY PxM~ PtaZSmS Xr j vSAc! y~Miv }SMj} AS <SMv} M ~ a cM~j UM} tHfAtv | sScS }cSA} cM~Mj} XuSwc jZjZ hMSwSuSZ

Ac1 PcSva PcSva SyMjf |At {SsSMr AciMrZ vS PpSMc? rS M~a PjS} cM} wYMr My, _ Pc{v csS?

_Z P|{v rSAvS hyrH
S A-} cvMz* iSH X c}Mr _ct{ zS~ ~SMe vS
XM} yZ PtdM~Z zZ cM} eSv eSZMr, vShMr cr zS~ ~SMe M~ |At cu a`M~SZ PdSr!
rSAvS}S Ac cu vSh-eSv AvMZ sScMr wSM} vS?

\} 2: e~t PrS AMM{

sScMr wS}r |At AM~yS yS ASyyS P }c{ r AM~ySM vSh-eSv vS sScSmS PrS ASyyS} e~t AMM{} e~t X zS~ vS ~SeM~a PjS} cM} c}Mr My jSrHZ ySwS}`M~S Ar {SvS |SZ vS Ac1 rS} jv ASyySmSMc wSSMvS} csS y~v y} y tSZ w}HS} aw} hS~SM~ h~My cH cM}? y~Miv ASAyt Z4vSs `

Y} |At w}HS AtMr ZMZ vS cM}?

Xv}SuS S{ eSv AvMZ wYSMSvS }yH4zS}rH PsMc _cmS M~ eSv PdSv
PiSmMy~S PsMcZ wYSMSvS c}Mr, zMeS~, X c}Mr X ~Ser Xv AtMc eSv PwM~ Y} AciZ hSZrS{ vS S PxSM} XSvZS~ w}HSZ tMmS AyMZ Px~ c}~S{ ySyS PoMc yM~AiM~v, _cm wYSMSvS vS c}M~ eSvmSa zS~ cM} eSZMr wS}My vS, {S Yj yAk P csSmS crmS Ar _dv eSMv} jeMra <ArM|SAerS {S}Sc! A{\AjMc Ay_ AoAmS YMi yM~ M~ hScA}mS PrS Xr Pw~S{

\} 3: AoA vS sScM~ hScA} cZ?

XsS _cmS PyAc AS}, AoA} <MZSjv PsMcZ |SM Xr Y{SMt} {MrS PtM P|dSMv AoA {SMv hScA} jHyv hS~SMvS w}HS rM~ PtaZS PSc, ySSMt} aw} hSw PtMyv vS, _Z AvMZ _r P| ZhZ Py, ~ UM} vS Z hSw AtM~v vS, SaZS, SA, eSMv yY Mr AtM~v, P|{vmS y~S M c}Mr rS} w}? }cS} Ac PZ YS AtMr wSM} P|, 18 yiM}} _cmS PiM~ yS P{MZ, P| cdva PcSva w}HSZ yMAv, P-a _cmS zS~ cSj wSMy? w}HS} jv _dv KrA} c}M~v vS, wM} YZ__ yS ySM} w}HS yS P| PcSva hScA}} w}HSZ cH y~Myv? Y{S} ySS hSw AvMr wSM} vS, aMc _{Av _{Av hScA} Atv? AjaSS Ay} Z4vSs `M}

vSh-eSv-iAy Y<cSMc _cS cSA}c~S} XSAfAzAmMj} {Mu }SdS} |e P, _mS {SvMrZ My AM{ yt~SMvS} t}cS}, PmSa vS P{Mv \wSZ PvZ Ac1 vSh, eSv, iAy Y<cS |SZ y~v vS Pcv, AvZ{SvyArrS, AvS} AycO PvZ PdSMva <ArM|SAerS} {MdS{Ad Mr wS}S} {MrS cM} AvMjMc eMY r~Mr My, {y tHf 11 yi} AcrS c}S eSZc Lw{ Z~SM{}

Ac1 AvZ{, On~S, _`M~S} AtMc PyA cM} PjS} AtMZ ySSMt} |0 cM} rM~ ~Sz?

\} 4: AvZ{On~S iSYS jHyv PrS ~z

jHyMv On~S, AvZ{SvyArrS ZrSAt} <MZSjv XwA}H{ Y} w}HSyyS, ~-cM~Mj} AvZ{ {SAxc jHyv, PmSZ ySSMt} SMr uM} AAdMZ PtZ, y~Miv rSwH }SZ _c{S PiM~ XAvT$ }cSA} M~ vy{ PAq

Ac1 wYSMSvS vS cM} PiM~ PrS Xv Aci c}MrZ wSM}? AvZZZ wSM} rMy _cmS U} w| <sSer wYSMSvS c}MrZ My vS M~ PcSvmS rS} je PmS AvyShv c}My cH cM}? Y} AvZ{On~Sa PrS t}cS} vS M~ yY aZSmSZ XDq PsMc |SZ, AyS rSwH}

{S-ySyS} M cr rc cM}Ai _cmS {Z w}HS, P}jS ZrSAt AvMZ ySYSySAY X ~Ser P<AMoA cM~Mj tv AvMZ Ay_ wYMr pMca PiMY AtMZAi AMv{SMmSSAx} PkS<c Ai~ y}Sy} PmSMcZ PwS AMMy PyMi Av~S{ cSja jmMr sSc~ _ Atc a Atc Ac1 Yj t yi} uM} fmSMr fmSMr {Mv Z wMq} _xAmYZ yS Y{SMt} _Y}_xAmYZ PsMc _cmS AoA |At sScr! |SMt} YMi rS}S wS cM} PyA}MZZ P| mScS} cSj wSM rS YA{ t yi} _Z <MxMv PsMca wSZ vS, Pdt, PSz, rSS} wS<hA{M~ \eM} AtM~v Ptyr yM2SwSuSZ

Ac1 PyA AoA-AmA PvZ rSa YwvSMt} PwSZ tSTq vS{oSc, _ }c{a PrS YMi \tS}q?
sScMy vS Pcv? cMZc ~SMd _cmS-tMmS PwMZZ |SMyv, PrMrS \} Ptyr}

rS M~ ArZ AoA ySwS}mS _r jTA}?

\} 5: w}HS vS AtM~ AvMjMc |ShSZ c}Myv cH zSMy?

w}HS yS AoA PrS YM~ _cmS XSMM{*m _y PZ XSMM{M*} x~Sx~ XsS AvMjMc |ShSZ cM} PvaZS} w$Ar M w}HS, {y {oSv SZ M~} A<AwS~ PtyH cM}}, w}HS rM~ AtM~ iS-iSH}S AvMjMt} z~-cAmmS ykMy cH cM}? Pc crmS Ad~, PmS crmS 2} zSMy rM~ u}Mr wS}My yS YMtR wS}My Ac vS, _ y ykMr PeM~ PrS w}HS AtMrZ My _ My} {Mu AtMZ vS PeM~ PrS jHyMv} yY {M| tS<YSMrZ wS}My vS

vS{ 2HS XS=SMZo SZMcS~Aj} cOrH iSH Xv wA}hZ PmA~AzMv} teS AA}ZSM~} teS _{_A P vS c}S w| } iSYS Hy vZ yM~ {GZMZ} _crS cwM}} AA}ZSM~} XxSM}a vS yM~ AtMZMiv

_r yY XxS} vS y~M~v?
Y{S} AyZmS YA{ dy zS~ySA {Mv Z wYSMSvSmS hSA~MZZ |SZ YM~ cH jSMvv, zS~ySS} AyZ AvMZ wYSMSvS c}M~ XMvc {S} {SuSv MZ |SZ _ PM YA{ A ZAoZm-_} tMv} M dSAvcmS _c{r rMy wYSMSvS} <MZSjv YMiZ PyAc _cmS AoA}a rS iSYS YwvS} jHyMv YwvS} A<ZjvMt}a PrS _cmS zA{cS YMi YwAv jHyv AvMZ jZS Pd~M~ rS} <zSy PrS rS<Mt} awM}a wYMy AvMj} wA}ySM}} <Ar _Z tSZy$rS} jSZeSmS zM~ PeM~ h~My cH cM}?

_cZ \} ^rwqS Pv`} P~Ao PMySMv} zS~ iSH AiM~v wYSMSvS, w}HS_Z AM{mS} {Mu sScS YwvSMc zAy jHyMv} |SyrHZ kYkS9S} jv <br cM} PtZ Y{S} cSMi <sSer AS}, w}HS} `T XwA}H{ P YwAv P| <MxvZ PyMi Avv vS Pcv

Ac1 AvMj} ZM} csS PzMy AvMj} {MrS cM} yS<hSmS Ac XvSZ?

\} 6: SHcOAr PwMr PeM~ <ArM|SAerSZ vS{MrZ My

AvMj} {MrS yS<hMr PeM~a Ac1 SAyc AycSM} <MZSjv Y} rS} jv <MZSjv AS}, y~Miv A2 M~} <uSv Ac S{vS}SZq yM2SwSuSZ
Ac1 _Z P| YjcS~ y~ S Z , wYSMSvS vS c}Mr hSZM~ PjS} c}Myv vS w}HSZ Px~ c}M~ ycSkcS vZ vS wMY cu eSv cvMr hSZM~ PmSZ c}Mr PtaZS \Ahr?
Ac1 AvMj} {MrS yS<hMr hSaZS PiM~Am yS P{MZAm |At yY MZ AvMj} ZM {MrSZ yY eSZMZ yS AhAOH Mr hSZ rS} jMva eSZMoM} <MZSjv, rSA~M{} <MZSjv PdSMva AvZ{SvyArrS, cMnS} XvH~v, w}HS Y} y PsMc yY csS ~, {SvM} SSzSAyc <yA M P}ceAvv SHcOAr P PcSva cSj c}M~Z XMv} Pc{v P~MeMi PmS jSvMr hSZ, XMv} {d PsMc rS} cSMj}, rS} A} <S cvMr hSZ Y}a zS~ eSv eSZMr PeM~, Y}a AydSr Mr PeM~, <ArM|SAerS _YSMyv cH cM}? <4 S{vS}SZqySy}

PZ SHcOAr Y} ~M} csSZ {SsSZ P}Md _MeSMv {ANcS }SZ ZM}AjMr _{_ h~Mi cM~Mj hScA}} PrSYMjS} M| PcSva PM <ArAr Mr PeM~Z hhS} t}cS}, t}cS} SuvS AvZ{On~S iSYS PmS Hy vZ YwAv P| AtMcZ _MeSv vS Pcv, <ArM|SAerS} {Mu wYMrZ My PmS PwA}MZZ ~ i<Mr My YwvSMc PmS zS~ vS M~ P| AciZ zS~ My vS

Y~ csS PySuZ _ZmSZ X~ Zj aMZ~ AySmS S PjSeSMvS} wM zS~ ZMrS rMy ySUy yY cAnv Y} PmS yM~, X~j aMZ~ tSm _ aMZ~ y zS~ |S} P zS~