Anandabazar Patrika

Anandabazar Patrika - Editorial

19 YS 1408 yuyS} 4  j~SZ 2001

<y 2..

c{SvZ S}?

PjS} PtaS t}cS} c{FMt} \wStvH~rS ySSMvS Ac _ AyM
XH{ tS`M} }Sj ySMjMm AyM PcSva csS PvZ A~dMiv

XAzLw }cS}

YS cM}Ai~S{ _cmS wA}yrv YMy YS cM}Ai~S{, }SrS}SAr PdS~-v~Mh vS yt~Sc, XsNvArc czyA$} AtMc, vrv wMs} AtMc _y P| wMs _dv S}S wAsyH <SmMi rS} AtMc Xr _cmS {t wA}yrv ~ c}y _ yiM}} ySMjMm {d}SZ PySu cA} YS cM} _cmJ rA~M zSyM~Z ykMr wS}rS{, P| Ys-S{SAjc vHAr yS{>*Mc _cmSvS 25 yi} }SjNvArc Sx~ _Mv AtMMi rSMc yt~SMvS} csS y$ \8Sta {Mv n@SZ PtMy vS Xr_y, er yiM}} ySMjm _y er 25 yiM}} yS{>M*} YAsc vHAr} M Ar P}MdZ _ yiM}} ySMjm c}S ~ XsS wA}yrv PcSsSa fm~ vS

_ yiM}} ySMjMm y PsMc PyA PjS} PtaS MMi c{SMv} \w} er yiM}} ySMjMma Cnc rS-Z MAi~ Xs{H XH{ tS` r@S} ySMjm AyyArMr yS} yS} {Mv cA}M AtMMiv, }Sj }cSM}} YAsc vHAr} {~ \M ~ }SMj c{Sv C c}S _y _Z c{Sv KrA} My {~r (AO _y SAv|A <cO`A~} {uyArrS _} jv XvtSv ASMy }Sj }cS} _cmS P{SmS mScS uS| cM}Mi YS c}S M, SAv|A, (AO _y }SA} }SWH AvMSe A{A~M _Z }SMj YeS{H yi} i ~ |yc-|yrH cSj wSMyv YwSrtCMr {Mv My, _ PrS dyZ zS~ csS }SMj PycS} |yc|yrH}S cSj wSMyv, hS} AtMc (AO eM \nMy, |>S}S Xv PcSsSa hScA} PwM~v vS r@S}S AvMj}SZ PiSmdSMmS <cMO SAv| Myv _} PsMc zS~ Y} cH Mr wSM}? ybr, yr{Sv AhMv _y Y}a YMe jSwSMv a tAq wy _AS PrS Cnc _Z zSMyZ ( \MtSMe} Azr} AtM AMO} AycS fMmMi wDZ{yMZ yS _Z yd-Xvr _y yd~SM x~ vHAr x~< My vS Pcv?

_Z <M4} \} PdS>jS} YMe, c{Sv csSmS} XsNvArc rSw| zS~ cM} PySkS t}cS} cS}q _Z csSmS yS{>M*} YAsc vHAr} y PsMc `Twq csS <s{r PySkS t}cS}, c{Sv cS} jv? cS}S _y cr jv _Z }SMj {MvS{r cSj wSMv vS? A&rHr PySkS t}cS}, _}S Pcv PycS} }MMiv?

_Z }SMj |>S}S <cr eA}y, XsS tSA}(H{S} YMwSM yS vHMh yS cM}v, r>S}S SuS}qr PycS} sSMcv vS }Sj yM~ v, S}S zS}MrZ _mS r PcSva eA}y {Sv PycS} sSMcv vS rS v, S}S yi} uM}Z P| cM~} cSj PjSMm rS-a v, rMy PyA} zSe {MZ PyA} zSe eA}y PycS} sSMcv vS rS} j cS}q, XAU}S} jv Aci vS Aci cSj, rS P |r c{ {jA}}Z PSc vS Pcv, r@SMt} c}MrZ  cSj vS c}M~ Pwm h~My cH cM}?

wSM}, PycS} sScMr wSM}v r>S}SZ |>S}S XMwScr XySw7 _y |>SMt} wA}ySM}} _cmS XsNvArc PjS} YMi MrS cS}a ySyS} _cmS Pwvv YMi, cS}a tStS} MrS yS YMi _cmS hScA} xM~ P{SmS zSr-cSwmS PcSva M{ jMm |SM _Z PycSM}}S P| dy Md YMiv rS P{SMmZ v, PycS}M} _cmS |qS PrS sScMyZ Ac cSj PvZ yM~ P| _}S cSj c}Miv vS, PmSa Cnc v PcSva PcSva PM cSj YMi, rMy P cSMj {jA} _rZ S{Sv P| rS c}Mr _Mt} {v hS vS

SAv|A DMca _cZ csS dSMm yd PMZ SAv|A <cMO} P}SjeS} YSvLw v rSZ _ ySwSM}a XMvMc} A&uS YMi _}S XMvMcZ {Mv cM}v, Y}a cMcmS Atv PtAd, MrS zS~ _cmS Aci jMm P|Mr wSM} rS iSS, cSMj} u}vmSa _dSMv jTA} ySgSA~ {uAy fM}} PiM~ |At hm cM} cSAc wA}M{} cSj c}Mr }SAj vS-v, rS M~ AyTM} Aci PvZ

XsS y~Mr hSZAi, PycS} P|mJc YMi rS YMi {~r XMwScr XySw7Mt} {Mu eA}y {SvMt} Azr} PycS} <S PvZ y~M~Z hM~ Y{SMt} PtM eA}y {SvM}S dS PyA rSZ Y{S} Xv{Sv r M~, _ PtM _y }SMj PycSM}} dS dy PyA aS} csS v YyS} eA}y {SvM} dS P|Mr M}} PsMc SM{ PyA, rSZ SM{} r~vS M}} PycSM}} dS PyA aS csS PtdS |Sc _ AyM wA}dSv cH yM~

1991 SM~} P~SceqvS Xv|SH wDZ{yM} c{MyA 50 rS wT PcSva cSj cM}v vS aZ jveqvS YyS} _Z rsa jSvSM P|, _ }SMj P{Sm wTMt} P{SmS{Cm 46-47 rS 19 yiM}} c{ yH |At uM} Av-Z _Z c{yH}S iSjHyv P cM} _dva cSMj} ySjSM} <My cM}vAv, rS M~ cSj d>jMiv _y wSMv vS _{v wTM} XvwSr t<SSM P{Sm wTMt} {S 3-4 rS _mS Xy dyZ P{SmS tSMe} _cmS AMy _Z AMMy} {Mu Ac-A{cMt} P|{v u}S Av, Pr{vZ YyS} u}S Av 19 yiM}} PyA yH iSMt}a XAr EAr vSvS~ SD~ SMz (_v _ _) yS jSrH v{vS {HS zS}Mr} AyAz7 }SMj c{Sv _y PycS}M} _cCm wnSvwn Ayy}q AtMMi S}Aq} _c _y tvG} c~{ PsMc wDZ{y- Y}a cMcCm }SMj} PycS} {S} dSAvcmS Y2Sj wSaS |SMy (S}AqCm _v _ _ 1999-2000, A}MwSm vG} 455 a 459-_} AzAMr KrA})

PtdS |SM, wT PycSM}} dS wDZ{yM} SM{ <Ar SjSM} 15 jv XsS 1.5 rS _y M} <Ar SjSM} 44 jv XsS 4.4 rS y~S t}cS}, _Z dS`A~ ~ P{Sm wT |>S}S cSj d>jMiv a |>S}S cSj c}Miv r>SMt} r~vS |>S}S cSj c}Miv r>SMt} XvwSr YM~ShvS} AyuSMs Y{}S {A~SMt} ySt AtD cS}q yd {A~SZ _ PtM cSMj} ySjSM} PpSMcv vS

S}Aq} _c _y tvG} c~{ PsMc Y{}S Xr ArvCm A$SM PwR>iMr wSA} <s{r, PycSM}} dS wAZ{y- PcSva }SMjZ {S}Sc }cM{} PyA v XsS jveqvS} wA}dSv PsMc Y{}S P| ~ AMymS PwMAi~S{ PmS jSrH v{vS {HS} ASMy} M P{SmS{Cm A{M~ |SM Y{SMt} A&rH A$S ~, PtM} yZ S{Hq PycSM}} XvwSr M}} PycSM}} r~vS c{ cS}q, YMeZ yM~Ai, SM{ eA}y {SvM}S dS PyA |>S}S y>ShS} jv Aci vS Aci cSj c}Mr ySu v rrHr, \MNAdr }Sj`A~} {Mu wDZ{yMZ dM} PycSM}} dS y PsMc PyA ybr, jSrH v{vS {HS} wq A}MwSm PsMc jSvS |SM M}} wT PycS}Mt} S} PeSS y PsMc PyA _y rS} wM}Z wDZ{y a XM{} Sv

\wM}} YM~ShvS PsMc PtdS |SM, wDZ{yM PycS} {S |rmS {Mv c}S  rrmS rH v XsS cu{S c{SMv} AtMc rSAcM yS{>* P| vHAr q c}Mi rS} PcSva XsNvArc P|RAcrS PvZ PycS} {S M} Xy YMi yS{>* _Z {S} {SuSv c}Mr hSZMi (AO _y SAv|A <cO`A~} {uyArrS _ ySwSM} rS}S x~ M vS Pcv? Y{}S YMeZ yM~Ai, dM} PycS}Mt} _cmS y X cSj cM}v vS cS}q cSj PsMc r@SMt} HSy P}SjeS} YSvLw v Pcv YSvLw v? cS}q \wStvH~rS tdjvc zSMy c{

S}Aq} Arv vG} c~M{ _Z Xv{SMv} {sv A{~My PtdS |SM, \wStvH~rS wDZ{y yS} PsMc AwAiM YMi ybr, _ ySwSM} _v _ _-_} wq A}MwSmCm wM~ jSvS |S, _c{S aAS _y AyS} iSS Y} {U }Sj \wStvH~rS Y{SMt} PsMc _AeM \MNd c}S P|Mr wSM}, _mS XeCnr PM} \wStvH~rS Y{}S _} AtMcZ rScSD, cS}q (AO _y SAv|A <cO`A~ _Z PM}Z Xer

yS{>M*} YAsc vHAr} e~tmS _ yS}  M \MnMi wDZ{yM} AzSe PycS} M} yS cM}v _}S PycS} sSMcv cS}q cSj PsMc, rS P (AOZ PSc yS SAv|A <cO, _Mt} P}SjeS} YSvLw v rS} cS}q _ }SMj \wStvH~rS z} c{ rS M~ yS{>M*} YAsc vHAr} PjS}mS wS \Ahr Ai~ \wStvH~rS yA$} \wM} c{Sv yA$} \wM} v YZ| _Z, \wStvH~rS AvM ySMjMm dy _cmS csS PvZ Xsh \wStvH~rS ySM~ c{Sv AvMj} PsMcZ KrA} r Yj PsMc |At YZv cM} S{-yS-P{MS P}M~} wA}yMr S}S M} cu A}c hS~SMvS} yM2SyU c}S r, c{Sv AvZ ySr _y \wStvH~rS XyZ c{r Ac rS} xM~ Y{}S Ac dy Md sScrS{? rS iSS, YS , ySMjMm P| _cMS PcSCm mScS _c ~ <cMO} {Mu zSe cM} PtaS} csS y~S MMi (XsS <cO Awi y}S {S t SjS} mScS, |S AtM \wStvH~rS ySSMvS XHy) PmS }SjNvArc <St Ayr}Mq} cSMj yyS} c}S My vS PrS?

P~dc c~cSrS ZASv SCmBcS~ ZvBCm\Mm XsvHAr} Ac